« /etc/links/Caught in the ropes like double dutch »

It's probably government computer chips that make me think the way I do

03/31/10

It's probably government computer chips that make me think the way I do

To illustrate the fundamental, and most important difference between the right and the left, I'll quote from "Whom Do You Trust?" from the conservative American Thinker:

The challenge to conservatives after the ObamaCare cram-down is simple. If we want to succeed in our quest of restoring limited government, we must persuade the American people of the truth: It is much better trust a businessman than a politician. If you want decent health care, then you don't want the government involved -- not if you don't want a $30-trillion unfunded deficit. If you want decent education for your children, then you don't want the government in the loop -- your kid will need remedial classes when he gets to college. If you want to give the poor a hand up and not a handout, then you need to keep the government out of it; otherwise, the government will end up smashing the low-income family.

Of course, if your idea of justice is to force the American people to pay for your education and your health care, then go ahead. Grow government.

This makes a lot of sense, that is if you're willing to ignore reality and go with ideology.

1. If you want decent health care, you can find it any country where the government runs the whole kit and caboodle. Take Great Britain, where healthcare is a lot cheaper per capita, "outcomes aren't noticeably worse" and you don't have to worry about the fact that you can't get chemotherapy in an emergency room.

2. If you want decent education for your chlidren, you'll do fine in public schools, even when compared to kids in private schools. (pdf)

3. If you want to help the poor, you need to realize that the "Great Society" programs cut poverty in half (from 1964 to 1974) in the U.S. I don't know of one corporation with that purpose in mind.

Government is often wholly inappropriate to address problems you might have. If you want to buy a tie, want a nice car or find a good glass cleaner, involving the government doesn't make sense.

But where government is an appropriate solution, it's better to put your eggs in the government basket. Politicians are elected and therefore directly responsible to the people, rather than profit. The profit motive often works against a clean environment, worker's rights, or truth in advertising. Yet it is also naive to trust the politician. Government can work, but only when it is composed of responsible and responsive leaders in government, elected by a vigilant and well-informed populace.

6 comments ». Categories: Politics. PermalinkPermalinkSend a trackback » 11:29:16 am by Ragamuffin

Trackback address for this post

Trackback URL (right click and copy shortcut/link location)

6 comments

Comment from: grygus [Member]
Perhaps the majority of Republicans are businessmen, wannabe businessmen, or people who idolize businessman. Blind trust is always dangerous.
03/31/10 @ 11:44
Comment from: ibotobob [Visitor]
"Of course, if your idea of justice is to force the American people to pay for your education and your health care, then go ahead. Grow government."

I love this line. I want them not only to pay for _mine_, but for everyone's. "People want government healthcare because they're egoists" is a nice twist. Sometimes being an egoist is altruistic. Say, when I'm chatting up a chick who has a boyfriend. How else is she going to ever enjoy my quality love-making?

Hm, somewhere in there I took the wrong turn :)
04/01/10 @ 07:58
Comment from: grygus [Member]
Yeah my idea of government is definitely to provide its citizens the best possible chance to succeed in the world. I don't know what the point of government would be, otherwise. If we don't want the government to protect and promote us, why do we need schools, museums, concert halls, police, fire departments, roads, signs, laws, or a government at all? Let's just all get guns and fend for ourselves as best we can.

OH WAIT. We all learned at age nine that a group is stronger than an individual. Maybe that's why.
04/01/10 @ 08:37
Comment from: Ragamuffin [Member] · http://keephip.com
Actually, I think the high schoolers reading Atlas Shrugs is the problem.
04/01/10 @ 08:39
Comment from: grygus [Member]
It's not the book but the perception that it's not fiction. Atlas Shrugged has some interesting ideas, but so does Firefly.

By the way, I'm not a big fan but if you've never read We the Living by Ayn Rand, it's actually quite good.
04/01/10 @ 10:14
Comment from: Ragamuffin [Member] · http://keephip.com
I wasn't being completely serious.

Yes I was.
04/01/10 @ 13:37

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)

September 2010
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 << <   > >>
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30    

Music. Technology. Books. And Political push back.

Search

XML Feeds